Decent Christian Fantasy Fiction (where in the heck is it?)

Since the baby was born, I’ve been catching up on my reading. This is working out great, because all my writer peers are running mega sales on their books to catch the shopping season. I’ve been chewing through a selection of Christian and non-Christian books, just to keep up with the cool kids.

So far, there’s been a marked difference between the two sorts of books. For instance, I’m currently reading The Pygmy Dragon, and it makes my jaded fantasy reader’s heart sing. A shapeshifting pygmy girl with super-strong magic, a fascinating dragon culture, an evil shadow-dragon, and a world of islands floating above a poisonous cloud sea? YES.

Or how about Rainbird? It’s a fantasy/sci fi novella about a world where a continent-sized dragon has crashed onto a world, and people have built a city inside its carcass, and use its eye as a sun. Except the dragon may not be as dead as all that, as our heroine discovers.

Whereas the Christian fiction I’ve read lately has been so lackluster. The bad guy is always Satan. The hero(ine) always wrestles with “OMG I have trouble believing in a God I can’t see OMG God’s love OMG John 3:16 OMG I should stop cussing.” (See my complete list of Christian book tropes.) No glorious flights of imagination. No sense of wonder. I mean, I’ve been reading Acts with the kids, and it’s so much fun. Paul and the rest of the early Christians had so much fire and enthusiasm–where is that in our storytelling?

That’s why I was so blown away by Rob Mullin’s Bid the Gods Arise. Here was the crazy fantastical voyage I wanted from my fat fantasy epic. I actually messaged him, “This is too good for Christian fiction!” which he found flattering. It starts off with two friends, one of whom is stuck in an arranged marriage to a princess, blaw blaw … and then during the wedding, an interdimensional slave ship appears, kidnaps everybody, and sells them as slaves on another world. The top of my head ASPLODE.

I had the same experience with Becky Minor’s elf-centric Windrider books. Although I find elves annoying, I enjoyed both the lyrical prose, and her snarky hero, who constantly lampshades various Christian fiction tropes. He’s like the Dresden of the high fantasy world.

I’m also familiar with Patrick Carr, Anne Elizabeth Stengl, Stephen Lawhead, Donita Paul, and a handful of others. All of them are pretty good. But there’s no breakout Brandon Sandersons, no soaring tales of dragons and magic and, well, fantasy. The fantasy market is plentiful and rich, especially with indie publishing opening the floodgates to zillions of talented authors. (Rachel Aaron, I’d never have found you without the indie world!)
So, my question remains … where is the decent Christian fantasy? And why isn’t there tons more of it?

4 thoughts on “Decent Christian Fantasy Fiction (where in the heck is it?)

  1. Two fantasy authors whose books I have enjoyed are Morgan Busse and Mary Weber. I’ve wondered too why there aren’t “tons” more, especially considering the flood we’ve seen from other authors on fantasy shelves in recent years. Many Christians read fantasy, but few seem to be writing it.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think there’s really good Christian fantasy out there,, but it’s harder to out them as Christian because their books are so good. I’ve been reading Marc Secchia’s dragon books, and they’re absolutely phenomenal. I only just learned recently that he’s a Christian. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I find so little time to read that I don’t read much Christian fiction, though I want to. Very interested in SF novel Methuselah Project by Rick Barry, after reading his action adventure Gunner’s Run.
    I’m trying to write good thrillers that often involve fantasy or SF, but I focus on telling a fun story with Christian protagonists who make choices from a faith perspective.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.